More on Kyle Williams. As I said in my initial post, he's not nearly a finished product. There's plenty of details he needs to learn about route running before he's done.
His success in college was due mainly because of his natural physical/athletic ability.
The most important part is the tools are there and he can be molded to grow right along with Drake Maye. Any decent NFL WR coach should only take about a month
to sharpen his route running. The things he doesn't do now are only because he doesn't know to do them. That's not his fault. Coaching will fix all that but then it's up
to him to apply those things on the field.
I rely heavily on studies done by a few people when I evaluate WRs. One of them is Matt Harmon who has a team that charts each receiver's routes and determines success
rate for each different route. Invaluable. Then they compare that success rate/kind of route with the actual # of routes he ran in games. IOW, did the coach use him to best advantage.
I can tell you, as much success as KW had on the field, his coach did not use him to best advantage.
Check out these graphs and you'll immediately see the discrepancies.
(In the first graph, the red arrow for screens should be a green arrow to reflect his 94% success rate.)
His most successful routes per the top graph are:
comebacks (100%), screens ( 93.8%), curls (88.2%), slants (86.8%) and flats (87.5%).
Now compare Route % (2nd graph)
comebacks (0.7%), screens (5.4%), Curls (17.2%), slants (17.8%) and flats (4.7%)
This kid should be running a higher % for comebacks, screens, slants and flats and LESS post and dig routes. His curl % was about right.
There's room to improve his success just by altering the routes he runs.
It's up to Josh McDaniels to use him properly.