PatsFan09 on 07-20-2007 at 11:02 AM said:
Here's how I see it:
Montana > Brady > Marino.
Why? Because WINNING is the only thing that counts.
By the way, want to know why most of us can't stand you?
It's not because of your backing of Marino. You're a Dolphin fan, go to town. Just don't expect us to EVER agree with your argument for Mr. Can't Get It Done In The Playoffs.
It's because of your pathetic conspiracy theory garbage. You have absolutely zero proof of it except for that lame, whiny St. Louis Rams fan site. If you were to drop that lame-arse schtick, you'd be half-way bearable.
Now you actually put Marino on the list...Although I disagree Brady is more talented than Elway & Marino or Manning...you were honest & gave your reason why without being out there & insulting & I repect that
This argument again is about pure "Talent" at the position of QB, and not about Brady bashing or Marino crap...it's about the Most Talented end of story...if we were talking about most SB rings & best playoff record...Marino is not in the conversation & if I said he was better than Brady...then you all call me a "NUTT JOB" but
You can say Brady Winning & he does but:
Marino has is 147-93 Top 3 All time winner starting as a QB 1 short of Elway's 148 & Favre is in there
You say Brady steps up in the Playoffs but:
Marino holds #1-2-3 All time Playoff TD's- Yardage-comp%
You say Brady etc..etc..and you know I'll rip out a record that Marino, Elway & many other QB's have over Tom Brady...doesn't mean he sucks..only means there are many that are as good as he is...my only point in this conversation is
He doesn't know how to win any better than any other QB I have mentioned, thats just silly to even say..
He doesn't hold any single NFL Quarterback records in the NFL as a Pure Passing QB even in single game & single season
He literally has nothing to legitimately claim he's a more Talented QB than Marino's, Elways & Mannings
He does have a great post season team record...
He does have 3 SB rings
He is a solid QB in todays NFL any team would love to have
But is he really a more talented QB than all these other QB's & if so why?...Do Not include team records...