Malcolm Butler Signed, Returning to Patriots for 2 Years

Status
Not open for further replies.
I love how you guys twist yourselves into pretzels. Benching Butler was the singular dumbest coaching move in SB history. Only topped by Bill bringing the guy back ... LOL
 
No twisting needed to see it was an easy first down instead of a turnover. Screenshot_20220404-091439_Reddit.jpg
 
Here are some "facts": Nick Foles: 28-of-43 for 373 yards passing and three TDs/one pick. 106.1 passer rating, averaged 8.67 yards per attempt.
 
I love how you guys twist yourselves into pretzels. Benching Butler was the singular dumbest coaching move in SB history. Only topped by Bill bringing the guy back ... LOL

So which tangent are you sticking with here? Bill made a stupid mistake benching him and then is stupid for bringing him back? Clearly that makes no sense so I'll take that as an innocent typo.

So is Bill stupid for a) Benching Butler or b) bringing him back. If you go with a) you must therefore be delighted in Bill's decision to bring him back?
 
So which tangent are you sticking with here? Bill made a stupid mistake benching him and then is stupid for bringing him back? Clearly that makes no sense so I'll take that as an innocent typo.

So is Bill stupid for a) Benching Butler or b) bringing him back. If you go with a) you must therefore be delighted in Bill's decision to bring him back?
Bill is the one that benched him in one of the 9 biggest games of his tenure as HC costing the Pats a SB win and a three-peat. Him bringing him back only shows how stupid he was for benching him in the first place.
 
Here are some "facts": Nick Foles: 28-of-43 for 373 yards passing and three TDs/one pick. 106.1 passer rating, averaged 8.67 yards per attempt.

So Foles outfoxed the Great Brady?? Yikes....And he also managed to catch a pass for a TD. Tom......well........
 
Bill is the one that benched him in one of the 9 biggest games of his tenure as HC costing the Pats a SB win and a three-peat. Him bringing him back only shows how stupid he was for benching him in the first place.
Ergo, it's a great decision. by Bill to bring him back. Got ya. Glad we got there in the end!
 
So Foles outfoxed the Great Brady?? Yikes....And he also managed to catch a pass for a TD. Tom......well........
Brady's stat line was better - 500+ yards, 3 TDs, no picks but his dummy coach cost him his greatest SB performance/win.
 
Brady's stat line was better - 500+ yards, 3 TDs, no picks but his dummy coach cost him his greatest SB performance/win.

Nothing on his missed, open net pass to James? Foles was 28 for 43, Brady was 28 for 48...all we needed was Tom to get that 29th pass reception and we were in business.

Shame.
 
Last edited:
Brady's stat line was better - 500+ yards, 3 TDs, no picks but his dummy coach cost him his greatest SB performance/win.

In that game, SUPER BOWL 52, Brady was put in a position to win the game late in the 4th quarter.

He failed.

In other SB's he did not fail. He is the GOAT QB, no question.

That said, he chose to ignore two wide open receivers and instead held on to the ball in the face of an oncoming rush. What was most important to Brady in that moment? The dink/dunk first down or the deep pass over the middle where he was staring the entire play?

In that moment when the Patriots needed him most, Brady was not the GOAT. He was Sam Darnold.
 
Last edited:
pure conjecture(butler playing would have led to a "w") vs. a factual observation about who was open? yeah...i'll take facts every time.
Amendola was standing literally right in front of him, even if he totally missed the wide-open James White read. Jenkins had to cover two of the best chain-movers in the game that year.

Edit: And he was in full backpedal. AND he wasn't exactly the best cover guy in the league as it is.
 
Last edited:
It's funny how it's twisting to talk about one play where Brady clearly made the wrong decision.

The twisting is trying to change the argument away from that.

Look at the play.
LOL. Brady had the best SB performance in SB history only to see it go down the toilet because of Bill's asinine decision. But that's ok, keep twisting. This is fun.
 
It's funny how it's twisting to talk about one play where Brady clearly made the wrong decision.

The twisting is trying to change the argument away from that.

Look at the play.
One play vs a player who didn't play at all?
Yeah that's twisting and Brady PTSD at its finest.
 
Not vs anything.

I am only talking about that play. No disorders here.

Can you not admit that play was Brady's fault?
Brady had several bad plays like any other game but cannot you not admit he was the best player on the field that night and he was let down tremendously by his defense punctuated by Bill's decision not to play Butler.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top