Top 20 Qb ratings in history

Share this page

midgar8784

midgar8784

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 31, 2007
Messages
54,669
Reaction score
1,561
Points
113
Age
52
With over at least 1500 pass attempts.

1
Steve Young
1985-99
96.81

2
Peyton Manning
1998-present
94.72

3
Kurt Warner
1998-present
93.17

4
Tom Brady
2000-present
92.93

5
Joe Montana
1979-1994
92.26

6
Carson Palmer
2004-present
90.12

7
Daunte Culpepper
1999-present
89.95

8
Chad Pennington
2000-present
88.89

9
Marc Bulger
2002-present
88.08

10
Drew Brees
2001-present
87.94

11
Jeff Garcia
1999-present
87.24

12
Trent Green
1997-present
86.9

13
Dan Marino
1983-99
86.38

14
Matt Hasselbeck
1999-present
86.23

15
Donovan McNabb
1999-present
85.78

16
Brett Favre
1991-2007
85.7

17
Jake Delhomme
1999-present
85.23

18
Rich Gannon
1987-2004
84.71

19
Jim Kelly
1986-96
84.39

20
Mark Brunell
1994-2006
84.21

Look, brady is 4th, did you see that d22....4th? Marino is 13th...ouch.
 
Jim Kelly was a better QB than Dan Marino.. at least he got his kicker to within range to win something. He also got to four SBs, that's three more than Dan.
 
LOL !!! what a putz ...LMAO!!!
 
Put Jim Kelly on Dans Dolphins teams and they not only go to four SBs in a row, they win three of them. Trent Dilfer would have won at least two with Duper and Clayton to throw to.
 
Quit spaming with these meaningless stupid threads that only children like yourself enjoy & think are valid points...

WoW!! even Peddington & Cullpepper, Hasslebeck and Bulger are all on this great top 10 list of QB"s of the Greatest QB's of All Time...you really are in a fvcking dream world...
 
midgar8784 said:
yeah Im the putz. Hey dumb dumb, where is brady ranked and where is marino ranked.
Click to expand...

Dan Marino an actual passing QB and started in 240 games
Tom Brady 80% of his completion from behind the line of scrimage and 10yd or less ...LMAO!
 
midgar8784 said:
yeah Im the putz. Hey dumb dumb, where is brady ranked and where is marino ranked.
Click to expand...

DAH!!! Hey putz...were is Brady ranked with a minimum of 200 games stating ?...OH Thats right he has 10 more years to be elligible for that great accomplishment...

"PUTZ!!!!
 
Maybe this is why "Glory boy" even has a top 10 Qb rating every year even if it averages 7th and 80% of his passes are 10 yds or less...here is were Brady ranks every year in Y/A and this is with YAC (Yards after the catch)

to be fair... unlike misleading Midgar...I added the QB's above him with 10 + games started that had a better Yards Per Average per pass.

The more i actually look at Brady the more Im convinced he really fvcking sucks & is nothing but a media whore...not a #1 QB...hes the king of Dink & Dunk...4 of 7 years he had from 15-25 QB's better than him throwing Y/A ...LMAO!!!

This is frigin hysterical,,,and pathetic at the same time...how does this "NOT" add up to a dink & dunking QB ? ...

2001 - 27th - 16 QB's better w/10+ GS
2002 - 41st - 25 QB's better w/10+ GS
2003 - 23rd - 15 QB's better w/10+ GS
2004 - 14th - 8 QB's better w/10+ GS
2005 - 8th - 4 QB's better w/10+GS
2006 - 34th - 16 QB's better w/10+GS
2007 - 1st - o QB's bwtter w/10+GS
 
So your numbers show that passing is overrated when it comes to winning Superbowls. Once again you've shown why Dan Marino failed to get it done year in and year out. He must have been thick headed like you and thought the only way to win football games is to heave the ball downfield and hope your guy catches it.

Tom Brady:

2001 - Won Superbowl and got the SB MVP
2002 - Didn't make playoffs
2003 - Won Superbowl and got the SB MVP
2004 - Won the Superbowl
2005 - Lost Division
2006 - Lost Conf Championship
2007 - Lost Superbowl

Now lets do Dans:

1983 - Lost Division (with a team that was in the Superbowl in 1982)
1984 - Lost Superbowl
1985 - Lost Conf Championship
1986 - Didn't make the playoffs
1987 - Didn't make the playoffs
1988 - Didn't make the playoffs
1989 - Didn't make the playoffs
1990 - Didn't make the playoffs
1991 - Lost Division
1992 - Didn't make the playoffs
1993 - Lost Conference
1994 - Lost Division
1995 - Lost Wildcard
1996 - Didn't make playoffs
1997 - Lost Wildcard
1998 - Lost Division
1999 - Lost Division


Wow, you really must love losers..

Dolphin22 said:
Maybe this is why "Glory boy" even has a top 10 Qb rating every year even if it averages 7th and 80% of his passes are 10 yds or less...here is were Brady ranks every year in Y/A and this is with YAC (Yards after the catch)

to be fair... unlike misleading Midgar...I added the QB's above him with 10 + games started that had a better Yards Per Average per pass.

The more i actually look at Brady the more Im convinced he really fvcking sucks & is nothing but a media whore...not a #1 QB...hes the king of Dink & Dunk...4 of 7 years he had from 15-25 QB's better than him throwing Y/A ...LMAO!!!

This is frigin hysterical,,,and pathetic at the same time...how does this "NOT" add up to a dink & dunking QB ? ...

2001 - 27th - 16 QB's better w/10+ GS
2002 - 41st - 25 QB's better w/10+ GS
2003 - 23rd - 15 QB's better w/10+ GS
2004 - 14th - 8 QB's better w/10+ GS
2005 - 8th - 4 QB's better w/10+GS
2006 - 34th - 16 QB's better w/10+GS
2007 - 1st - o QB's bwtter w/10+GS
Click to expand...
 
PatsRUs said:
So your numbers show that passing is overrated when it comes to winning Superbowls. Once again you've shown why Dan Marino failed to get it done year in and year out. He must have been thick headed like you and thought the only way to win football games is to heave the ball downfield and hope your guy catches it.

Tom Brady:

2001 - Won Superbowl and got the SB MVP & Cheated *
2002 - Didn't make playoffs Cheated & still "Sucked"
2003 - Won Superbowl and got the SB MVP "Cheated" **
2004 - Won the Superbowl Cheated ***
2005 - Lost Division Suched & still cheated
2006 - Lost Conf Championship Sucked & still cheated
2007 - Lost Superbowl The Biggest "Choke Job in History 18-1 ...

..
Click to expand...

Belichick* Kraft and Goodell have proved it definately pays to cheat and disrespect the NFL...
 
Dolphin22 said:
Maybe this is why "Glory boy" even has a top 10 Qb rating every year even if it averages 7th and 80% of his passes are 10 yds or less...here is were Brady ranks every year in Y/A and this is with YAC (Yards after the catch)

to be fair... unlike misleading Midgar...I added the QB's above him with 10 + games started that had a better Yards Per Average per pass.

The more i actually look at Brady the more Im convinced he really fvcking sucks & is nothing but a media whore...not a #1 QB...hes the king of Dink & Dunk...4 of 7 years he had from 15-25 QB's better than him throwing Y/A ...LMAO!!!

This is frigin hysterical,,,and pathetic at the same time...how does this "NOT" add up to a dink & dunking QB ? ...

2001 - 27th - 16 QB's better w/10+ GS
2002 - 41st - 25 QB's better w/10+ GS
2003 - 23rd - 15 QB's better w/10+ GS
2004 - 14th - 8 QB's better w/10+ GS
2005 - 8th - 4 QB's better w/10+GS
2006 - 34th - 16 QB's better w/10+GS
2007 - 1st - o QB's bwtter w/10+GS
Click to expand...


Brady is 4th all time in Qb rating...4th. I'm not sure why you ignore this, it really amazes me. But he is 4th....4th. No matter what you show me you are just ignoring the fact that he is 4th all time....4th. Also brady has the same Y/A that marino does, so it seems dink and dunk marino not only dinked and dunked, but couldnt win superbowls either.
 
Wah.. if that's your excuse, why couldn't Shula help Dan out while he was on the competition comittee? He could have done a rules emphasis like Polian did for Manning or something to that effect. When they cheated in 1972 it worked out great for them, they won a SB.

So what we've learned is that everyone cheats, some get caught, and some cheat better than others. Dolphins can't even cheat good anymore.. how sad is that.

Dolphin22 said:
Belichick* Kraft and Goodell have proved it definately pays to cheat and disrespect the NFL...
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top