Hm. I'm only a few episodes in and I don't find it all that bad. Season 3 (with Jimmy Smits) was a stinker, IMO.
Thanks to those who use spoiler tags in this thread.
Actually it's almost the same angle they went with last season. They should have learned from the third season that it just isn't a good idea. I won't go into detail to not spoil it, but yeah, I think it falls in line with season three if you ask me.