FO grades every team's FA work.
Seattle was able to re-sign Comeback Player of the Year Geno Smith to a bargain-bin contract, which in turn allowed them to invest heavily on defense.
www.footballoutsiders.com
New England Patriots
Improved Roster: C+
Used Resources Well: B
Coherent Plan: B-
Overall Grade: B-
The Patriots entered the offseason with needs at wide receiver, tackle, and cornerback. After making signings at all three positions, the Patriots' biggest needs after the first wave of free agency are … still wide receiver, tackle, and cornerback.
That being said, New England has improved their offensive weapons. Despite Mike Gesicki's decreased role in 2022, he still posted higher receiving DYAR and DVOA than Jonnu Smith while also out-gaining Smith in receiving yards and catching five touchdowns to Smith's zero. JuJu Smith-Schuster actually placed one spot above Jakobi Meyers in both receiving DVOA and DYAR and is a much more effective scorer, with 29 career receiving touchdowns in six seasons to Meyers' eight in four . Both contracts represent massive value for New England as well. Gesicki's total contract value of $4.5 million is less than one-third of Smith's $15 million, according to OverTheCap. While Smith-Schuster and Meyers both signed deals for $11 million per year, Smith-Schuster has less guaranteed money with a lower cap hit in 2023. Neither is the No. 1 receiving option New England needs, however, improving their floor but not really changing their offensive outlook.
One of the biggest losses from New England's offseason comes in the retirement of safety Devin McCourty, but the remaining safety group of Kyle Dugger, Adrian Phillips, Jabrill Peppers, and Jalen Mills (transitioning from cornerback) can provide a wide range of coverages and better disguise their assignments pre-snap. Despite re-signing cornerback Jonathan Jones after a breakout season, the Patriots still need a top-end cornerback to add to this secondary.
If one thing is certain, Bill Belichick will never finish last in special teams DVOA again. The Patriots retained special teams ace Matthew Slater and added Cody Davis while cutting punter Jake Bailey. In addition, New England signed former Lions linebacker Chris Board, whom Belichick described last season as "the best special teams player we'll play against all year."