Would you trade Mac for Carr

[mikiemo83]

At 5 pm next Sunday evening?

I mean why not. Carr knows Josh’s offense and BO’B’s similar

 

[TommyD420]

At 5 pm next Sunday evening?

I mean why not. Carr knows Josh’s offense and BO’B’s similar

If Judon and the top 4 CBs on the roster weren't on IR, I'd seriously consider it. At this point, you may as well try to develop Mac some more, because this defense is going to be atrocious in spots now.

 

[BostonTim]

Ah, sweet mystery of life. Mac Jones is our QB1 Mac Jones is our QB1 Mac Jones is our QB1. Would you trade Mac for Carr?


Cheers, BostonTim

 

[chevss454]

No. Carr is playing poorly for NO and now he has a mild AC jt sprain of his throwing shoulder. Besides, he flunked in our system in Vegas under Josh.
I don't see how he'd be an upgrade.

 

[HomelessJoe]

Carr is old and we know he sucks. Mac is young and we're only like 70-80% sure he sucks. Stick with Mac.

 

[Flagg the Wanderer]

I remember a year where, after a slow start and horrific week 4 loss, a reporter asked Belichick if he was evaluating the idea of benching Brady...

 

[HSanders]

I remember a year where, after a slow start and horrific week 4 loss, a reporter asked Belichick if he was evaluating the idea of benching Brady...

and bb snorted derisively. no snort this time.

 

[imapig]

 

[Big/Sky/Fly]

I remember a year where, after a slow start and horrific week 4 loss, a reporter asked Belichick if he was evaluating the idea of benching Brady...

Mac is no TB12

 

[Alk]

If Carr was healthy, yes. There are also a good number of other QBs that I would trade Mac for too. Hell at this point I would trade him for whatever the hell they can get for him and ride out the season with some FA scrub and try to find the answer at QB in the next draft...and the draft after that...and the draft after that and...

 

[Flagg the Wanderer]

Mac is no TB12

Nope. Not even close. My point is about the overreactions to an atrocious performance.

 

[Alk]

Nope. Not even close. My point is about the overreactions to atrocious performance(s).

FYP

 

[ParanoidPatriot]

I have pondered this question for several seconds and I vote no.

 

[Roberto71]

No way. We're stuck with Mac for the rest of the season. The team can then make a choice post season about how to move forward,

 

[chevss454]

No way. We're stuck with Mac for the rest of the season. The team can then make a choice post season about how to move forward,

Pretty much.

 

[Patriots-Lifer]

If Judon and the top 4 CBs on the roster weren't on IR, I'd seriously consider it. At this point, you may as well try to develop Mac some more, because this defense is going to be atrocious in spots now.

This does complicate a lot of things.

Injured Christian Gonzalez, Matthew Judon ‘out indefinitely’ while seeking second opinions, per report

The two defenders were hurt during Sunday’s loss to the Cowboys.

www.patspulpit.com

 

[Darth Despot]

No.

It won't help enough to justify the capital used for a trade.

 

[PumpDee]

No way. We're stuck with Mac for the rest of the season. The team can then make a choice post season about how to move forward,

Literally the only sentence we will see on this board containing "the team" and "post season" this year.

 

[3 Point Stan]

Would rather keep the mediocre QB on the rookie contract than trade for a mediocre QB with a $100 million gty'd contract.

 

[O.Z.O.]

At 5 pm next Sunday evening?

I mean why not. Carr knows Josh’s offense and BO’B’s similar

For what purpose? What would Derrek Carr give you other than potentially a lower draft pick?

I've seen 3 of the first 4 games. I'm unimpressed with the entire operation at this point. Sloppy special teams play, turnovers and an entirely underwhelming showing by the offense to this point. I know wants to hang around and beat that dead asshole's wins record but good God this is ugly. Fortunately, we're Pats fans and we've seen this before.